Cherry-picking corncrake data to manipulate news
Published:
-
-
Author: Dara Bradley
~ 2 minutes read
From this week's Galway City Tribune
Bradley Bytes – A sort of political column by Dara Bradley
Junior Minister for Nature, Malcolm Noonan, issued a statement welcoming a 2024 survey from the National Parks and Wildlife Service (NPWS) that apparently showed a 7% increase in the national corncrake population, or 15 additional birds compared with 2023.
“Furthermore, the numbers of corncrake territories recorded in the core breeding areas of Donegal, Mayo and Galway have increased by 45% on 2018 baseline figures,” the press release gushed.
It sounded great. So, we asked for more details about Galway aspects of the survey. Silence from NPWS and that organisation’s parent Department of Housing. When follow-up queries were ignored, we submitted a Freedom of Information request to get the survey.
But it turned out, the survey does not exist – yet.
“I wish to advise you that the report is still being drafted and may not be ready until the end of October 2024,” the Department said in response to an FOI request.
When the ridiculousness of the situation was pointed out – how can you issue a statement about survey results for a survey that does not yet exist? – the Department doubled down.
“It is not unreasonable or unusual to have headline figures confirmed without the detail of the report fully ready for release,” said a senior Department of Housing official.
No explanation was given as to why the press release couldn’t have waited until the survey was ready in October.
Essentially, what happened here folks, was that figures from incomplete surveys were cherry-picked and published to manipulate the news cycle to suit a Green Party Minister’s agenda.
Cynics might conclude it was released to garner positive publicity, ahead of a possible November election, or to deflect from negative news.
What’s worse, some media outlets published it without probing the data further. It’s for the birds!
Pictured: For the birds: Minister Malcolm Noonan’s statement welcoming a 7% increase in the national corncrake population,was based on a survey from the National Parks and Wildlife Service that has not yet been fully collated.
More like this:
Last chance to apply for Údarás na Gaeltachta green skills scheme
This article first appeared on Galway Bay FMThere are just a few days left to apply for a green s...
Galway tourism companies showcased at London event
This article first appeared on Galway Bay FM60 tourism companies from across Ireland, including A...
UHG has country's highest number of 'stuck' patients – still in hospital despite being cleared for discharge
This article first appeared on Galway Bay FMUHG has the country's highest number of what are term...
DJ Carey sentence hearing deferred as court hears he's in Portiuncula Hospital
This article first appeared on Galway Bay FMDJ Carey’s sentence hearing for defrauding people by ...
Status Yellow rain warning for Galway and Mayo from noon tomorrow
This article first appeared on Galway Bay FMA Status Yellow rain warning for Galway and Mayo come...
DJ Carey’s sentence hearing pushed out to Friday after the judge was told he's in Portiuncula Hospital in Ballinasloe
This article first appeared on Galway Bay FMDJ Carey’s sentence hearing for defrauding people by ...
800 social homes at design or construction stage in Galway
This article first appeared on Galway Bay FMAlmost 800 new social homes are either under construc...
No restoration date in place for catering services on Galway to Dublin trains
This article first appeared on Galway Bay FMIrish Rail says reports that catering services on ALL...
Transport Minister urged to prioritise funding for Western Rail Corridor
This article first appeared on Galway Bay FMThe Minister for Transport is being urged to prioriti...
Sign Up To get Weekly Sports UPDATES