The amount of ‘compensatory habitat’ being provided as part of proposals for the N6 Galway City Ring Road is excessive.
That’s according to a representative for McHugh Property Group, which owns over 100 acres of land in the Menlo area including Lackagh Quarry.
Senior Counsel Dermot Flanagan told the An Bord Pleanála oral hearing on the proposed €650 million road development that his clients believed proposals to use in-filled parts of the quarry to re-create calcareous grassland – a specific type of grass that grows in limestone areas – were unnecessary.
According to Mr Flanagan, evidence submitted to the hearing by ecologist for the GCRR project, Aebhín Cawley, indicated that 0.25ha of calcareous grasslands would be lost to the road, but 7.14ha of compensatory land was to be provided as part of mitigation measures (for habitats which would be ‘lost’ to the ring road).
Furthermore, he said Ms Cawley had stated that the ratio of compensatory lands should be one-to-one or greater – adding that what was being proposed was far in excess of this.
Ms Cawley said she wished to clarify that the “bare minimum” of off-setting for lands lost should be one for one, but that it should be greater – and that they were also including for the limestone pavement being lost.
A large proportion of the limestone pavement on the eastern side of the new ring road was situated in a European Special Area of Conservation (SAC) and a tunnel near Lackagh Quarry has been included to avoid impacting the protected landscape.
There are a number of areas of limestone pavement not included in the SAC, but do have Annex 1 status meaning it was a habitat of significance, although does not have the same protected status of a SAC.
Ms Cawley said there would be an inability to replace the limestone pavement lost in these areas if the proposed road were to go ahead and so they had made provision to provide additional compensatory areas – providing like for like and then adding to it.
Mr Flanagan said the ratio was extraordinarily above what was required and put it to Ms Cawley that it was simply the case that the opportunity to provide this grassland had arisen due to the in-filling of Lackagh Quarry.
However, Ms Cawley said there were in fact two areas of Lackagh quarry where there would be no material deposits in-filled that were proposed for replacement grasslands.
Mr Flanagan said both he and his clients agreed with Galway County Council – the lead authority on the GCRR project – that adequate limestone pavement had been protected within the SAC, but said there was adequate replacement grasslands being provided in areas outside Lackagh Quarry.
He said his clients had proposed alternate sites for use to replace the grasslands lost, but these had been rejected by the Council.
Mr Flanagan said that lands in the ownership of Galway City Council were suitable for this purpose and so the requirement to issue a Compulsory Acquisition Order on Lackagh Quarry could be avoided.
Ms Cawley said the lands proposed by Mr Flanagan’s clients were not suitable for recreating the habitats required.
On the purpose of these lands after works had been complete, Mr Flanagan questioned if they would be used for agricultural grazing, as recreational facilities, or as some other public amenity.
Ms Cawley confirmed that there would be no public access to the lands after construction.
Meanwhile, Mr Flanagan sought clarification that over three hectares of his client’s lands that were earmarked for use as a site compound would only be subject to a temporary acquisition and would be returned to its original owner once construction was completed.
A spokesperson for project designers ARUP confirmed that it would be reinstated and returned once the Ring Road was completed.
GSPCA closes city centre charity shop permanently
From the Galway City Tribune – It’s the end of an era for a popular animal charity shop that has shut up shop for good at its city centre base.
The Galway SPCA (Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals) has confirmed that it has not renewed its lease on its premises at St Augustine Street, where its charity shop has been based for a number of years.
The popular shop that sold books, clothes and bric-a-brac closed in June due to a leak in the building. It was due to reopen within days, but it has not and will not be, according to the charity.
The GSPCA said they are looking for a new premises in the city.
A spokesperson confirmed that the lease on the building was due to finish soon anyway, but after a major leak, the GSPCA and the landlord mutually agreed to bring forward the lease termination by a number of months.
“We hope to be up and running at another location in due course,” a spokesperson said.
A register charity and not-for-profit organisation, GSPCA still has a retail presence in Athenry and Ballinasloe, which generate money to run the organisation.
Its fundamental aim for over 20 years has been to care for animals in need through neglect, abandonment, abuse or those at risk due to a change in circumstances.
Its main sanctuary is based in the county, between Killimor and Portumna; and its cattery is in Athenry.
The charity assisted over 700 cats, dogs and smaller animals during 2020. According to accounts filed with the Charity Regulator, the vast majority of its income comes from donations, but its shops are important income sources and the charity made over €86,000 income from “trading and commercial activities” in 2020.
Workers in Galway still waiting for ‘frontline’ payments
From the Galway City Tribune – A number of workers in healthcare settings in Galway have yet to receive promised pandemic bonus payments for toiling on the frontline during the Covid-19 crisis.
The Government had pledged each front-line worker would get a €1,000 payment as a thank you for contributing to the national effort during the pandemic.
But nine months on from when the Cabinet signed off on the payment, many local workers, including nurses and carers, particularly in private nursing homes, have received nothing.
Louis O’Hara, a general election candidate for Sinn Féin in Galway, labelled it as another broken promise by this Government.
“Workers here in Galway such as caterers, cleaners, security staff, agency staff and many more on the frontline in our local hospitals and healthcare settings have been contacting me to express their concern that they are still waiting for this payment,” he said.
“They are entitled to receive this payment, however the Government has failed to follow through on their promises and workers have been left in the lurch with no answers and no sense of urgency from the Government,” he said.
Mr O’Hara told the Galway City Tribune that the Minister for Health, Stephen Donnelly, needed to clarify that the funding was still there to pay the staff.
He said a breakdown of figures for the number of staff in Galway that were not yet been paid was not available, but Sinn Féin has been inundated with complaints from workers – particularly agency staff and those in private nursing homes.
“Frontline workers in Galway have been let down badly by this Government’s failure to follow through on their promises. This is absolutely unacceptable,” Mr O’Hara said.
The party’s Health spokesperson has written to An Taoiseach Micheál Martin, urging him to intervene directly to ensure this payment is paid promptly.
Minister Donnelly, in a recent reply to a Parliamentary Question in the Dáil, said priority was given to payment of eligible staff in hospital groups, such as Saolta, and community services within the HSE.
He said that the Department of Health was “examining progressing the rollout” to six groups of non-HSE and Non-Section 38 Agencies, who were included in the scheme.
These include eligible workers in private nursing homes and hospices; staff on-site in long-term residential care facilities for people with disabilities; agency staff working for the HSE; healthcare assistants such as home help, home care and home support staff contracted by the HSE; Defence Forces members redeployed to work “in front-line Covid-19 exposed environments in the HSE”; and paramedics employed by Dublin Fire Brigade.
This was a “complex task”, he said, because “these employees are not normally paid by the public health service, duplicate payments need to be avoided, and there are many organisations to be covered”.
This work was being given “priority attention” he said.
“Payment to eligible workers will be made as soon as possible,” Minister Donnelly added.
Murals are part of initiative to restore pride in Ballybane estate
From the Galway City Tribune – A poem about litter forms part of a vibrant colourful new mural painted on the walls of a City Council estate in Ballybane.
The poetry and artwork by local artist Irene Naughton is part of an initiative to restore pride in Sliabh Rua.
The final two lines of Ms Naughton’s poem, called The Dragon’s Foot, read: “The land, the sea and the river all get hurt when we leave a littered footprint on the earth.”
The full poem was painted onto boundary walls as part of a large colourful mural that was created by Ms Naughton.
The street art includes handprints from children living in the estate on the city’s east side.
It also depicts an enchanted forest, a dragon sitting atop Merlin Castle, a view of the Burren, a wolf, butterflies, insects and foliage, as well as a man playing the guitar, a former resident who died.
Ms Naughton, who was commissioned by the City Council’s Environment Department, said it took about five days to complete.
“The residents were very, very helpful and kind,” she said.
Councillor Noel Larkin (Ind) explained that the mural was part of a wider, ‘Ballybane Matters’ project, which stemmed from Galway City Joint Policing Committee (JPC).
“We were doing a lot of talking at the JPC about anti-social behaviour, and it seemed to be more prevalent in the Ballybane area. When we boiled it down, it was in the Sliabh Rua and Fána Glas areas.
“Month after month it was just talking. So Níall McNelis [chair of the JPC] said we should set up a small group to hone in on exactly what was going on,” he said.
A group was formed to focus on improving the Council estate of about 40 houses.
As well as Cllr Larkin, it included: Sergeant Mick Walsh, Galway Garda Crime Prevention Officer and community Gardaí Maria Freeley, Nicola Browne, Kenneth Boyle and Darragh Browne; Fr Martin Glynn; Imelda Gormley of Ballybane Taskforce; Councillor Alan Cheevers; Donal Lynch, chairperson Merlin Neighbourhood Residents’ Association; and two members of Galway Traveller Movement, Katie Donoghue and Kate Ward.
Ms Gormley carried out a survey to get feedback from residents.
“A lot of the problems people had were horses on the green, people being harassed going in and out of estates, trailers full of rubbish left around the place, the City Council not cutting the grass, and anti-social behaviour,” explained Cllr Larkin.
Small improvements, with community buy in, has helped to revitalise the estate.
Cllr Larkin praised Edward Conlon, community warden with the City Council, who has been “absolutely brilliant”.
“He looked funding that was available to get trees or shrubs and to get the grass cut more regularly,” he said.
“Fr Martin got a residents committee set up because he knew people through the church, and that means there is community buy-in, people are actually taking an interest now.
“When we started originally, Sergeant Mick Walsh mentioned ‘the closed curtain syndrome’. You go into your home in the evening close your curtain and don’t want to see what’s going on outside. Whereas now, with community pride restored to the area, if somebody is acting the maggot outside, people are keeping an eye on it and that curbs anti-social behaviour,” said Cllr Larkin.
Covid-19 delayed the project but it “came together very quickly” once work started.
Cllr Larkin said that the project will move to other estates in Ballybane, including Fána Glas and Castlepark, but they also plan to maintain the progress made in on Sliabh Rua.
“We decided to concentrate on Sliabh Rua, because if we could crack Sliabh Rua we could crack the rest of them. Pride has been restored in the community,” added Cllr Larkin.