The threat of a three-year sentence hangs over a couple who violently mugged three young women in separate attacks as they walked through the city on their way home from work and college on a winter’s evening.
One of the victims sustained a fractured elbow as well as extensive bruising to her body as one of the muggers dragged her along the ground at Eyre Square in an attempt to steal her handbag. She also suffered a deep gash to her left knee and had to be treated at UHG for her injuries that evening. The other women suffered minor injuries when they too were attacked from behind and dragged along the ground.
While their physical injuries have healed, all three continue to suffer from the mental scars left by their attackers, all stating in their victim impact statements to a court this week that they no longer feel safe to walk the streets of Galway alone at night.
Rosanna Cawley, who is now 23, and from the Bog, Poolboy, Ballinasloe, and her then-partner, Willian Toohey, now 20, from Mountrath, Co Laois, pleaded guilty moments before their trial was due to begin before a jury at Galway Circuit Criminal Court in February 2020 to robbing a Canadian medical student’s handbag, her iPhone and iPad worth €735 at St Nicholas’s Street on November 5, 2018.
Toohey also pleaded guilty to attempting to rob another woman at Bóthar Breandán Uí Eithirr on the same evening and to assaulting a third woman, causing her harm, outside the entrance to the shopping centre in Eyre Square, also on the same evening in 2018.
Judge Rory McCabe directed probation reports on both accused and remanded them on continuing bail to November 4 last for sentence. They brought €1,000 compensation to court for the victims on that date but the court was told they had missed several appointments with their probation officer and were not co-operating. It also heard Cawley had given birth in the interim.
Judge McCabe adjourned sentence to March and then to last week’s court to give the pair another chance to comply with the probation service.
Garda Michael Gallagher told the sentence hearing this week that at 5.30pm on November 5, 2018, Gardaí were alerted to a woman whose bag was pulled from her shoulder in Eyre Square. She was attacked from behind and knocked to the ground, sustaining injuries to her elbow and body in the fall. Gardaí received a report a few minutes later from a Canadian medical student who had been injured when she was dragged along the ground after her bag was pulled from her shoulder near St Nicholas’s church.
The bag contained her laptop, iPhone, lecture notes and bank cards.
Shortly afterwards, Gardaí received yet another report from a third woman who said she had been the victim of an attempted robbery near Prospect Hill but had managed to hang onto her shoulder bag, even though she had been injured in the attack. Cawley was found in possession of one of the victim’s handbags when the couple were arrested a short time later.
Garda Gallagher read the victim’s separate impact statements into evidence.
The woman who was mugged in Eyre Square said the attack affected every day of her life since. She said she was dragged along the ground towards a steel pole and tried to move her head out of the way. The muggers ran when her head hit the pole.
She sustained a deep cut to her knee and damage to her neck and back. She had to seek counselling afterwards and can no longer walk alone in Galway City. She no longer carries a purse or handbag and will not go out in the city on her own after dark.
The medical student’s mother had to travel from Canada to care for her daughter after she was attacked. Her head hit the ground hard, she said, and her medical notes were taken as well as her phone and iPad.
The third victim said she had just finished her first day at work in a new job and was almost home at 6.30pm when she was attacked. She let out a roar and managed to stay upright while hanging on to her handbag which was ripped apart during the attack.
To be attacked outside her home was unnerving, she said, in her statement and she no longer trusts people. She too had to receive counselling after suffering panic attacks in public.
“I’m afraid to be alone in public anymore and I’ve no independence left,” her statement concluded.
The couple offered no explanation for their actions that evening, although Cawley claimed she drank two naggins of neat vodka and two cans of beer earlier.
The court heard the couple had brought another €1,000 to court for the victims.
Judge McCabe said the pair were looking at a three-year sentence as the victims had been left ‘out of the blue’ with physical and mental scars.
However, he said he would adjourn finalisation of sentence to November 3 to see how the pair continued to rehabilitate while under probation supervision.
No monkeypox cases recorded so far in Galway
The Health Protection Surveillance Centre (HSPC) has had no reports of monkeypox infection in Galway so far.
So far, some 97 confirmed cases have been notified in Ireland, including 12 new notifications in the week to July 30.
But none of these cases were notified in the HSE’s CHO2 area which includes Galway, Mayo and Roscommon.
The latest epidemiology report about human monkeypox was released last week.
All of the 97 notified cases in Ireland are males and have a median age of 36.
The sexual orientation of 75 of the men is known, and they self-identify as gay, bisexual or other men who have sex with men.
The HSPC said this epidemiology of the infection is similar to other countries.
A total of ten people have been hospitalised with the infection; four of them required clinical care for monkeypox infection while two were admitted for observation.
The HSE said monkeypox is a very uncommon infection that produces a spotty, itchy and sore rash, and sometimes a fever.
It is caused by a monkeypox virus which is naturally found in some animals in Africa. The HSE said it was in the news now because there have been several thousand cases of monkeypox in countries where the virus is not found naturally, including Ireland.
It is spread through close contact, including sexual contact, but it can be picked up through contact with objects touched by an infected person such as sheets.
Monkeypox symptoms can appear in two stages. The first stage usually begins with a sudden onset of fever and chills, followed by a bad headache, swollen glands and exhaustion. There may also be muscle ache, backache, cough and runny nose, and gastrointestinal symptoms such as vomiting and diarrhoea. Not everyone with monkeypox has these initial symptoms.
One to three days after the fever starts, an itchy rash appears. It may first appear on the face and spread to other parts of the body. Some people may only have a rash and not initial symptoms.
Anyone with symptoms is asked to contact their GP.
Law catches up with Galway parking meter thief years later
From the Galway City Tribune – The long arm of the law stretched back through the years, finally bringing a man to justice this week for stealing almost €3,500 in coins from parking meters in the city six years ago.
42-year-old Ioan Costin, a Romanian national with an address at 20 Brewery Court, Ballinrobe, was taken into custody on July 11 on foot of three separate bench warrants issued for his arrest when he failed to appear before courts in Galway in 2017, and more recently Dublin and Castlebar.
He was facing charges in Galway in 2017 of damaging a parking meter at the Long Walk, belonging to Galway/Aengus Property Management on July 6, 2016, and with stealing €669.90 in coins from the meter on the same date.
He was further charged with stealing €932 in coins from another parking meter at the Docks, the property of Paul Sheridan, c/o Port of Galway, on October 2, 2016, and with damaging that machine on the same occasion.
Costin was brought in custody before Galway District Court on July 18 – a week after the bench warrant was executed – where he pleaded guilty to the above charges and to further charges of damaging four other parking meters at or near the Docks area on various dates between July 4 and 19, 2016.
In all, coins totalling €3,451 were taken from the meters over the four-month period, to which he also pleaded guilty.
In one raid alone, Costin and another man, who was never identified or caught, stole €1,800 in coins from one meter at the Dock Road on July 6, 2016.
He was also found in possession of two screw drivers which he used to force the meters open during one of the July raids.
Both men were captured on CCTV, damaging the meters and stealing the coins, following a Garda investigation into the targeted attacks on parking meters in the Docks area at the time.
Costin made full admissions to Garda Ronan Leonard following his arrest on July 11 last.
He claimed he had a gambling addiction and went straight to Salthill on each occasion with his share of the stolen coins, where he lost them all on slot machines.
Defence barrister, Ernie White explained to Judge Gerard Furlong at the holiday sittings of the court this week that his client was first brought in custody before Galway District Court on July 11 last where he pleaded guilty to the charges and sentence was adjourned to this week’s court.
Sergeant Christy Browne, prosecuting, said Costin had 17 previous convictions, all of which were for thefts and for having implements to commit thefts. The most recent conviction, he said, was recorded at Castlebar Circuit Court on July 15 last where Costin received a three-month sentence for a theft which he committed in May 2020. He had also received suspended sentences at a court in Dublin the previous day for similar thefts and for having screwdrivers to commit thefts in 2017.
Noting Costin had made no attempt to repay the money in the intervening years, Judge Furlong sentenced him to five months in prison for damaging the meter at The Long Walk and imposed a concurrent five-month sentence for the theft of the €3,451. Both sentences were backdated to when the Costin went into custody on July 11. The judge took the remaining charges into account and granted leave to appeal the sentence.
Arts building must be provided in any overhaul of Galway Docks
From the Galway City Tribune – A three-storey structure to accommodate the arts in Galway City could become a reality as part of the regeneration plans for the extensive Inner Harbour site at the Docks.
And Galway Harbour Company has stated that as part of any redevelopment of the site, they are very supportive of the provision of arts and cultural facilities on their lands.
Caroline Phelan, Senior Planner with the City Council, told a Galway City Development Plan (2023-29) discussion that they would consider the provision of 1,500 square metres of arts space on the site by the eventual developer.
And she said that this could involve the construction of a three-storey structure and would be embraced as part of the overall Harbour extension and all councillors present at the meeting welcomed such a move.
Ms Phelan added that any such development would be limited to a certain size and would be done in conjunction with the City Arts Officer. An audit of arts and culture requirements would also be carried out.
The City Development Plan meeting was discussing a submission from the Galway Harbour Company which outlined a proposed masterplan for the overall site which it said would be required.
It is envisaged that the site will be ‘built out’ in two phases and should require a separate masterplan for each phase, in the context of the overall planning framework.
However, as part of this massive plan, it is required the provision of an arts and cultural facility at a developer’s expense and with a management regime incorporated into the development delivery that enables the long-term sustainable use of such a facility.
“Galway Harbour Company are entirely supportive of the provision of arts and cultural facilities on their lands as part of the regeneration of the area and will actively accommodate such facilities.
“However, the requirement as set out in the draft plan is considered to be unduly onerous particularly as our client has no involvement in or expertise in this sector.
“The Galway Harbour Company will make a site available for an arts and cultural facility and will work with all relevant parties to ensure that this facility is delivered and that it is sustainable in the long term.”
It was requested by the Harbour Company that that this requirement would be reworded along the following lines: “Provision will be made within the masterplan for an arts and cultural facility and the delivery and management regime for this facility will be devised in collaboration with Galway City Council and other relevant stakeholders.”
Cllr Donal Lyons (Ind) at the outset asked if it would be a small, medium or large artistic facility and inquired if there would be a minimum space available for the arts as part of the Harbour regeneration plans.
But he did express the view that it was a major step towards the provision of such facilities at the Docks and it would “foster artistic purposes”.