The mother of a 25-year-old man who died by suicide told an inquest into his death she was looking for help but didn’t get it.
The man, with an address on the outskirts of Galway city, took his own life in November, 2016, following his discharge a month earlier from University Hospital Galway’s Psychiatric Unit.
His mother told Coroner for Galway West, Dr Ciarán MacLoughlin, that her son was admitted to hospital on September 21, 2017 and was an in-patient for 18 days.
She was critical of the decision to discharge her son and, in particular, the lack of notice given to her that he would be coming home.
She said she had tried to meet with hospital staff but had been left waiting so long on one occasion, she had to return to work.
“I was surprised when they rang and told me he was being discharged; nobody asked did he have somewhere to go.
“Yes, he was an adult, but he was still a sick adult,” she said.
She told the Coroner’s Court that once her son left the hospital, he refused to take the medication that had been prescribed for him.
“He wasn’t willing to go to the pharmacy to get medication – he just wasn’t right,” she said. “He thought this medication was killing him.”
Consultant Psychiatrist, Dr Camilla Hennelly, treated the deceased at hospital during his admission in September 2017.
Speaking to the inquest, Dr Hennelly said he was a self-referred patient and that it had been his first presentation to the services.
“He presented with a three- month history of low mood, poor appetite, broken sleep and paranoid and suicidal ideation.
“He had been drinking for two years previously culminating in low mood,” said Dr Hennelly.
“He was abstinent on presentation for a period of two to three months,” she added.
She said he had been on anti-depressants but compliance had been an issue and he could not recall the name of them when asked.
In the early stages of his admission, he was placed on level two observations which involved him being checked every 15 minutes by a psychiatric nurse.
He was also prescribed anti-depressants and anti-psychotic drugs, explained Dr Hennelly.
“He engaged with the therapist and a recovery care plan was put in place and this was discussed with his mother.
“He denied any cravings for alcohol during his admission and on September 25, following review by me, I increased his anti-depression medication,” said Dr Hennelly.
She said on October 2, his depression symptoms were abating, as was his suicidal ideation.
“By October 9, I was satisfied that he should be discharged for therapeutic reasons,” said Dr Hennelly, before explaining that certain services are not available to psychiatric patients while they remain in hospital.
He was advised to attend the day hospital and group therapy sessions and was told of the importance of taking any medication prescribed for him.
Coroner, Dr MacLoughlin, said it was all very well to say he wasn’t displaying psychosis at this point.
“He was dead within a month by his own hand.
“There seems to me an awful lot of concern by his mother and it would appear that concern wasn’t taken on board by a lot of other people,” said Dr MacLoughlin.
His mother said her son did not leave the house for a month after discharge; had been so afraid at night that he was sleeping in the bed with her; and he refused to take any medication.
She said she had tried to contact Dr Hennelly at one point but she was on leave and her call was never returned.
Dr Hennelly said she was never made aware that her patient’s mother had called upon her return.
The deceased’s mother said she had reached despair on October 13 and called for an ambulance, only for the paramedics to inform her that because her son would not go willingly to hospital with them, it would be up to his GP or the Gardaí to sign him in.
“The ambulance person rang the GP to ask him to sign [my son] into hospital but the GP refused and said I have nothing to do with that and to ring the Guards,” she said.
Giving evidence, the deceased’s GP, Dr Denis Higgins, said he had no record of that call and while it could have been taken by another GP at his practice, he personally did not speak to any paramedic.
The mother said she would seek to find the paramedic to corroborate her story, should the Coroner allow it.
Legal Counsel for the HSE, Imelda Tierney, said that the deceased had been engaging with the services after his discharge from UHG.
“He had an 18 day stay in hospital – that is not often the case. He received detailed treatment over that 18 days.
“He returned to an appointment on October 18 so he was engaging with the system,” said Ms Tierney.
Coroner, Dr MacLoughlin, said it seemed his mother had a deep insight into the problems her son faced.
“Ms Tierney, what you are really saying is that all the professionals thought he was alright and the only person who knew how sick he was, was his mother – and who was right?
“I feel it is incumbent on me to make enquiries on this and see what the general attitude in the hospital is to this,” said Dr MacLoughlin.
He said he would give the deceased’s mother the time she needed to find the paramedic whom she said had called the doctor.
“I will reserve a verdict and any rider or recommendation until such a time as we have heard complete evidence. We will reconvene on June 28/29,” said Dr MacLoughlin.
Italian archer brings whole new outdoor leisure pursuit to Loughrea
An eagle-eyed Italian has converted a cohort of locals in Loughrea into archery enthusiasts – in the heart of their local forest.
Mattia Cestonaro set up Loch Riach Traditional Archery, the first field archery club in Galway to be affiliated to the Irish Field Archery Federation (IFAF).
After raising nearly €800 in public donations, he established the course geared to different levels in a forest located in Peterswell on the Slieve Aughty Mountains.
Field archery has participants shooting at various targets. The targets may be concentric circles, animal faces on paper or 3D animal targets, from a variety of distances, which can be marked or unmarked.
There is a main course layout in a loop shape, where small groups of archers, typically up to four, walk around and stop at each station to hit a target.
The club is a non-profit organisation with the main aim to promote our beloved sport in Ireland.
“This is a sport for everyone, we have kids, adults, families shooting together. It’s some mighty fun,” enthused the native of Vicenza in north-eastern Italy.
“This is an exciting new activity for the local community, as well as to visitors from other counties and clubs.”
Mattia has created three small bridges to cross the river in different points using pallets on the course located on over 160 acres of forest. There are currently 14 targets spread out over 1.5km, crossing different types of terrain.
The club teaches a ‘traditional, instinctive way of shooting’.
“It is a challenging course with different tricky shots, uphill, downhill, between trees. We tried as much as we could to use natural backstops to make the shots look as natural as possible,” he explains.
“We think our club as a group of friends who share the same passion, we organise many social activities and we encourage members to volunteer in the club’s activities.”
The main course is made entirely of 3D targets.
“We believe there is nothing else like the sight of a realistic 3D target in the forest.”
Several of the first courses held last July sold out. The courses in August completely sold out.
It costs €50 per person for four weekly classes lasting an hour and a half, with the minimum age of eight set for participants. Archers aged under 18 must have at least one parent participating in the course with them. Adult membership of the club costs €60 for the year, while kids pay €30, which includes membership to the social club.
“There was an overwhelming response to our first beginner courses and an ever more surprising conversion rate, which saw the 100% of those who completed the course become members of the club. This was amazing and already repaid the months of hard work in the woods,” enthuses Mattia.
The club will now concentrate on making sure all the new members receive proper support during their first months in the archery world.
Mattia was doing field archery in Italy but took a few years off until he got the opportunity here over three years ago to reignite his passion.
“I went back into it thanks to my friend Enea, who is the son of the iconic Italian character Papetto, who is one of the greatest masters of Instinctive shooting and whose values and philosophy he is trying to promote and keep live for over 45 years.
“This is the same I’m trying to do with the club, I am offering beginner courses where we cover all the basics of field archery and where I try to spread my archery philosophy which has the social aspect of this discipline in his core values.
“To put it in simple words, I’m in love with this sport, and I try to transmit my passion to other people.”
The Italian moved to Ireland from Italy in 2014 looking for a change in lifestyle. After three months in Clifden, he transferred to Galway and found a job in supply chain with Schneider Electric, where he continues to work.
In December 2020 he bought a house in Loughrea and moved in with his partner Tatiana.
“It was a huge step in our life, and we couldn’t be happier with our choice. We found a lovely welcoming community, everyone is so kind with us and there is so much to do around here: from the lake which is at our doorstep, and we walk daily with our dogs, to the numerous sport activities available.”
Mattia plays with the Loughrea Rugby Club and recently helped organise a group of 14 Italian teenagers to visit Loughrea from his old club, the Rangers Rugby Vicenza. They stayed with host families and trained with the Loughrea RFC for a week.
Mike Feerick of Ireland Reaching Out said he and wife Eileen regularly get behind the bow and arrow on a Sunday morning after completing a beginner’s course earlier this summer.
He has praised Mattia’s hard work, with the support of Coillte, in turning an area of Slieve Aughties into a recreation hub.
“It’s interesting that someone has come to live among us and helped us strengthen our community, starting a new pastime in the locality which takes advantage of the wonderful hinterland we have in East Galway.”
“It is a big undertaking for any one person – but he has persevered and indeed succeeded.”
Mattia has plans to expand the course with new targets and create a bigger training range.
“We plan to create nice picnic areas for members to spend time together with benches and tables and some shelter for the rainy days. We also plan to host the first official IFAF shooting in 2023, where people from other clubs from all Ireland will come over to compete as part of the IFAF annual calendar,” he explains.
“The future ahead is exciting, and I am very proud to be able to offer something different to a community which is giving so much to me and my family in terms of quality of life.”
Hurdle cleared for Claregalway traffic calming and flood relief scheme
A dispute over land acquisition that threatened to sink a long-awaited traffic calming scheme and flood relief works in Claregalway has been resolved.
A meeting of the Athenry Oranmore Municipal District councillors heard that an agreement had been reached with the landowner, enabling the Council to proceed with its plans to install a surface water drainage scheme at the bridge.
Cllr Jim Cuddy (Ind) said following repeated representations, he had been assured that a resolution had been found.
“I have been informed that we are waiting for Transport Infrastructure Ireland (TII) to come back to the Council to tell them to proceed,” said Cllr Cuddy.
This came as councillors hit out at the lack of progress on the project, with Cllr James Charity (Ind) pointing out that it had been three years since they approved the project.
“I have had a lot of complains in the last few days about flash flooding in Claregalway, on the street outside Centra . . . we’ve mentioned it in here ad nauseum,” he said.
“It is very frustrating for communities and residents up there that this is not progressing – it’s a long-standing problem that’s being put on the long finger.”
Cllr Albert Dolan (FF) said it was disappointing that having approved the project in 2019, councillors were being kept in the dark and had received no official communication from the National Roads Project Office (NRPO) to explain the delay.
“It’s three years on and we have not seen any progress . . . the Athenry Oranmore councillors are not happy that this has been delayed for so long without being given a reason,” said Cllr Dolan.
Cllr Charity suggested that a representative of the NRPO should be invited to a meeting of local area councillors to explain the lack of progress.
“If the matter is progressing, we need an update from them. Resolution with the landowner is one thing but the TII committed to this in 2019, so now there is a question of funding as well,” said Cllr Charity.
Cllr Liam Carroll (FG) concurred and said with the increasing cost of construction materials, funding would need to be addressed without delay.
HSE-owned houses have been left lying empty for past four years
A local councillor has expressed his fury at the fact that two structurally-sound houses in Gort have been lying idle for the past four years by their owners, the Health Service Executive – despite families locally crying out for a home.
Cllr Gerry Finnerty wants a system put in place to insist that the owners of any long-term vacant properties should ‘use it or lose it’.
The two adjoining houses at located in a prime location on the Ennis Road in Gort and while they are structurally in good shape, they have become overgrown and there is even vegetation growing out of the chimneys.
According to Cllr Finnerty, the imposing two-storey properties could each house a family of five or six if they became available on the market.
The councillor has raised the deteriorating state of these two houses with the HSE on a number of occasions but has not got any satisfactory response.
“They are just sitting on their hands,” he remarked.
“Shame on them at a time when people are really struggling for accommodation and these two dwellings could easily be brought back into use before they deteriorate any further,” Cllr Finnerty added.
The houses were originally owned by Gort Mental Health Services – but due to running costs, upkeep and a lack of clients it was decided to offload these properties which were then taken over by the HSE.
At the time it was expected that the HSE would put them to some use, but they have not been occupied since they acquired them and parts of the dwellings are now boarded up.
The properties have their own entrance, two large rear gardens and two car garages. However, on closer inspection, some of the tiles are falling off the roof and there is vegetation growing out of one of the chimneys. The exterior has also become overgrown.
Cllr Finnerty explained that the HSE had been approached by both himself and a number of concerned asking them to either sell them off or utilise them but the response has been vague.
“No state body should be allowed to leave property vacant at any time not to mind in a housing crisis that currently. It should be a case of use it or lose it.
“The Government are out of touch in relation to what is happening out there. This is just one example of property that could be occupied going to waste.
“If the amount of vacant properties were brought back into use, it would certainly go some way towards addressing the crisis,” he said.