Classifieds Advertise Archive Subscriptions Family Announcements Photos Digital Editions/Apps
Connect with us


Jury finds man not guilty of glass attack




A Galway jury may have set a new record by returning a unanimous verdict just nine minutes after it had retired to deliberate on evidence given during a two-day assault trial.

The four women and eight men were sent out to deliberate at 3.38pm and pressed the buzzer in the jury room nine minutes later, indicating they had reached a unanimous verdict, finding Eamon McDonagh (26), of 19 Sliabh Rua, Ballybane, not guilty of a single charge of intentionally or recklessly causing serious harm to Dominic Downes at Glenbaun, Ballybane on June 1, 2014, contrary to Section 4 of the Non Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997.

Downes lost the sight in his left eye after he was stabbed repeatedly with a broken bottle during an altercation between two gangs of youths but the jury did not accept his evidence that he recognised his attacker.

McDonagh denied the charge and his trial commenced last week at Galway Circuit Criminal Court.

Mr Garnet Orange, SC, defending, told the jury McDonagh had celebrated his birthday the previous night and he had been at home on the night the attack took place.

Prosecuting barrister, Conor Fahy told the jury it was the State’s case McDonagh had stuck a broken bottle into Downes’ eye a number of times during a fight.

McDonagh did so intentionally and he had acted recklessly, he added.

The trial heard Downes and others had been drinking heavily in town on May 31, 2014, before returning to Daniel Barry’s house at 15 Glenbaun, Ballybane that night.

They continued drinking there but Downes left the house at one point and assaulted a youth nearby before returning to the house.

Barry went missing from the house a short time later and his mother sent Downes and two other youths out to look for him.

There was a lot of “activity” going on outside in the general Ballybane area that night with people jostling and fighting each other, the court was told.

Downes said they met a gang coming towards them.  He said he recognised Eamon McDonagh in the gang.

He turned with the others and tried to run back to Barry’s house but the gang caught up with them.

Downes said Eamon McDonagh wanted to know who had assaulted the youth earlier and one of the other youths pointed him out.

Downes said he told McDonagh he wanted a “fair fight” and they started to swing at each other.

Downes told the jury he was a good boxer and he was getting the better of McDonagh in the fight.

Someone then jumped him from behind and he was held down.  McDonagh, he said, came at him with the broken bottle.

“I seen him coming at me and stabbing me in the face,” he told the jury.

During cross-examination, Downes told Mr Orange he never carried a knife but later admitted he carried a knife for protection.

He said he didn’t know McDonagh that well but said he recognised him. He admitted being involved in other violent incidents himself involving other people.

Sgt. Shaun Durkan told the trial Downes was reluctant to make a statement of complaint initially but finally did so last January. He said no witnesses came forward to offer any independent evidence even though other youths were present at the time of the attack.

He agreed during cross examination by Mr Orange that there were no witnesses, no phone records and no CCTV – which would link his client to the attack.

In his closing speech to the jury, Judge Rory McCabe asked jurors if they could rely on Downes’ evidence.

He said it was the State’s case McDonagh intentionally stabbed Downes in the eye and that he had lost his sight in that eye as a result of the assault.

However, he said, there were no witnesses, no phone records or no CCTV linking the defendant to the assault.

The victim, he said, had a history of violence and he admitted carrying a knife.

“And what opportunity did he have to recognise the accused?  We’ve heard there was a lot going on that night and a lot of drink taken.

“The difficulty you have is can you rely on the evidence of the victim? There’s no doubt the injuries that were sustained amount to serious harm.

“The real issue is does the evidence prove beyond a reasonable doubt that this harm was caused by the accused man?,” Judge McCabe cautioned.

McDonagh, who had been held on remand at Castlerea Prison prior to the trial, walked free from court with members of his family seconds after the jury acquitted him.


Outpatients’ concerns over reduced services at Merlin Park

Dara Bradley



Patients who use ‘Hospital 1’ at Merlin Park face uncertainty over services after nurses were re-deployed to University Hospital Galway.

The hospital unit carries out infusion and transfusion services, as well as oncology and haematology.

Saolta University Hospital Group – which operates the public hospitals –has transferred nurses from Hospital 1 in recent weeks, so that it had sufficient staff available to reopen St Anthony’s Ward at UHG.

St Anthony’s is a 28-bed ward that had been closed all during Covid-19. It has now been re-opened, using redeployed nurses from Hospital 1, to cater for the return of essential procedures at UHG.

Saolta has argued that it is trying to maintain core services at UHG and it is re-deploying staff from elective areas in Merlin Park.

Merlin Park and UHG combined is Galway University Hospital – essentially the same workplace for industrial relations purposes – and is part of the same umbrella of hospitals in the West and North West run by Saolta.

A number of outpatients who have used Hospital 1 have told the Galway City Tribune they are concerned with the change, and the implications it might have on the services they receive.

Hospital 1 is a medical ward that offers a Monday to Friday service on the first floor of the main building on Merlin Park grounds.

They do infusions and transfusions and treat patients with MS, those who are anaemic, as well as oncology and haematology.

Those impacted by the reduced service at Hospital 1 also include people with blood disorders; people with blood cancers or leukaemia; and people with conditions such as myelodysplasia.

“Neurologists use it to observe patients who’ve had seizures. There’s a multitude of consultants who would’ve used Hospital 1 for various investigative procedures. Rather than going into hospital in UHG, occupying a bed, Hospital 1 is used for infusions, and you could be in and out in a day, or stay a couple of nights,” a source said.

The Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation (INMO) has called on Saolta to put in place a contingency plan.

Anne Burke, INMO, Industrial Relations Officer, Western Region, confirmed to the Galway City Tribune that some of her members have been re-deployed from Merlin Park to UHG, because of a massive shortage of nurses at the Newcastle site.

“If they pulled the Hospital 1 nursing staff out of UHG today, St Anthony’s would have to close and that’s the nub of it. They simply do not have the staff to do it,” explained Ms Burke.

“The staff have redeployed. They were initially told it would be for two weeks. But clearly, that won’t be sustainable in the context of massive vacancies at the UHG site.

“There’s bound to be a very definitive impact on the service. We have members already working overtime, and part-time workers who have upped their hours. But you are only flogging a dead horse if you’re asking people to work over and above. There’s only so much overtime you can do – no matter what money is offered – in the context of the conditions on the wards,” she said.

Asked when Hospital 1 might return to ‘normal’ staffing levels, Ms Burke said: “When is it likely to revert? There’s a big question mark over it, and our position is that it’s an unanswered question in the context of the deficit of nurses at UHG site and the attempt by management to maintain core services.

“That might be of cold comfort to those who depend on transfusions in Hospital 1. But they are going to have to put in a contingency plan about all of this and how it’s going to be managed and how Joe and Mary Bloggs who is looking for an infusion or transfusion, how are they going to get that. They cannot just be left in abeyance. They have to receive some element of treatment. Whether that is done through engagement with the private hospitals again, we don’t know.”

The recent cyber attack on the HSE has hampered INMO’s ability to communicate with hospital management.

Continue Reading


Hundreds of new apartments in Galway will not be available to buy

Enda Cunningham



The backer of the Crown Square scheme in Mervue is planning a massive ‘build to rent’ housing scheme as part of the development, with 345 apartments.

Padraic Rhatigan was previously granted permission for 288 apartments on the site but has now applied for a modified and higher-density development, with blocks ranging from four to nine storeys in height.

There will also be a neighbourhood facility with a gym, a primary care medical centre with pharmacy, a ‘working from home’ lounge, games room and a creche.

There will be 240 two-bed apartments, 86 one-beds and 19 three-beds, all of which will be specifically for the rental market and not available to purchase.

The plans include three blocks ranging from five to nine storeys in height, with garden courtyards.

To meet social housing requirements, the developer plans to transfer 35 of the apartments (20 two-bed, 10 one-bed and 5 three-bed) to Galway City Council.

A total of 138 car-parking spaces have been allocated on the lower basement levels of Crown Square for residents, and there will be 1,200 secure bicycle parking spaces across the development.

The planning application was made directly to An Bord Pleanála under ‘Strategic Housing Development’ legislation, which allows for the Board to decide on applications residential developments of more than 100 units following initial consultations with the local authority.

According to Rhatigans, the property market has changed since it was granted permission in November 2019 for 288 apartments in three blocks ranging from five to eight storeys in height.

“The rationale behind this proposal stems from the changes to market modelling and the demand for residential accommodation which have arisen since the previously approved application.

“These amendments … are being proposed following a review of the economic viability of the overall scheme,” the applicant previously said.

According to the new application, the scheme is intended to create a “distinctive new city quarter”.

“Important pedestrian and cyclist connections are also incorporated into the design by creating links between Monivea Road and Joyces Road providing an accessible street network for walkers and cyclists. It is considered that the proposed development would bring significant socio-economic benefits to the community,” the application reads.

The apartments constitute Phase 2 of the Crown Square development. The first phase is already under construction and includes a 180-bed hotel with bar, restaurant and conference facilities and five office blocks with space for up to 3,500 workers.

Mr Rhatigan recently told An Bord Pleanála that despite uncertainty in the market with hotels at the moment due to Covid-19, there is still a plan to proceed with the hotel in Phase 1 “and broadly with the masterplan for the overall scheme”.

He explained that the substructure of the hotel was currently being put in and that Rhatigans are in discussions with a few potential operators, but are not as far along in the discussions due to the delays brought about by Covid-19, however, it is believed to be still viable.

It remains the intention to be a high-quality hotel with a good-branded operator on board, he told the Board.

Two of the buildings in Phase 1 are expected to be completed with landscaping and occupiers moving in at the end of this year.

Continue Reading


City Council ‘does not outbid’ private buyers in housing market

Dara Bradley



Charities that buy houses in Galway for homeless people are not distorting the property market, a senior official at City Hall has said.

Dermot Mahon, Acting Director of Services for Housing at Galway City Council, insisted that Approved Housing Bodies (AHB), which provide and manage rented social houses, do not outbid private buyers in the housing market.

He was responding to queries from elected members before they approved a loan of almost €1 million to facilitate three AHBs to buy four city homes.

“We don’t engage in a bidding process,” Mr Mahon said. “We take a value, and we will not exceed that value. If there are other purchasers we will not engage, and we will not exceed it [valuation].”

He said that there is a cap in all local authority areas set by Government regarding the maximum amount that can be paid to purchase houses for use as social housing rental properties.

Councillors agreed to approve loans of €930,000 for the purchase of four homes.

The agreement included €202,355 to Galway Simon for a two-bed house off the Western Distributor Road in Knocknacarra; some €189,264 to Cope Galway for a one-bed apartment on Dominick Street; and €246,528 and €292,279 respectively to Peter McVerry Trust for two-bed and four-bed houses in Doughiska.

Funding is provided by way of a grant from the Department of the Housing to the local authority who provides the funding to the relevant AHB in the form of a 30-year mortgage. Loan charges are waived provided the terms of the scheme are complied with.

“All properties have been supported by an independent valuation and represent good value for money,” said Mr Mahon.

He said that Simon and Cope were two organisations that had “excellent records” in Galway.

Mr Mahon said that Peter McVerry Trust is “in the market for more property” in Galway.

The Trust already operates the Modular Family Hub in Westside on behalf of the Council, which is a temporary facility to house people who are homeless in accommodation other than hotels and B&Bs.

Two families from the Westside Hub will be relocated to the two new properties bought in Doughiska.

In response to several questions from councillors, Mr Mahon insisted that the method of allocating housing was “transparent”.

“There is no queue skipping – it is done in consultation with us,” he said. It is based on need and length of time on the housing waiting list.

Cllr Alan Cheevers (FF) called on the Council to carry-out full surveys of houses before they are allocated to tenants.

He pointed to a recent situation in Doughiska where homes were allocated to tenants but the properties were ‘faulty from the get-go’, which was not acceptable. The issue was decided on in the courts, he said.

Mr Mahon said the four new properties being discussed were compliant with planning permission and had been assessed by engineers.

Continue Reading