A 23-years-old woman who punched and kicked another young woman until she was unconscious and then stole her mobile phone from her lifeless hand, walked free from Galway Circuit Criminal Court.
Judge Rory McCabe asked Sadie Keary, of 17 Fana Glas, Ballybane, what was so amusing when he looked down and caught her smiling to herself as a Gardai recounted the vicious assault she perpetrated on a 22-year- old woman outside McSwiggan’s in Woodquay in the early hours of August 1, last year.
Keary pleaded guilty before Galway Circuit Criminal Court in May to the robbery of a €300 mobile phone from the young woman at Woodquay that night.
The facts in a second charge of assaulting the girl, causing her harm, were admitted at the time.
Sentence was adjourned to last week for the preparation of reports.
Garda Pat Foley told the sentence hearing the victim, whom he described as a shy and softly-spoken college student, was sharing a joke with her boyfriend and two other friends while standing in a doorway at McSwiggan’s at 3.05am that night when Keary and a group of other girls came along.
Keary, who had earlier consumed Ecstasy tablets with alcohol, thought the girl was laughing at her and she became extremely aggressive. She reached in past the girl’s boyfriend and despite his best efforts, she pulled his girlfriend out onto the street by her hair.
She punched the girl in the face, knocking her to the ground and then punched her again on the ground before kicking her twice in the head.
Judge McCabe interrupted the Garda’s evidence when he spotted Keary laughing.
“Are you amused by this? Do you think that it’s worth laughing about?”, he asked her.
She looked at him evenly, shook her head and said “no”.
Garda Foley resumed his evidence.
“On losing consciousness, the injured party dropped her phone from her hand and the defendant picked it up and fled on foot with the group of females,” he said.
Garda Foley said he was on foot patrol in the area at the time and found the injured girl lying in the doorway of the pub, her friend cradling her in her arms.
“She was dazed, confused and she was bleeding from her face and nose.
Her clothes were blood-soaked.
“I asked her what had happened but she didn’t have a great understanding of what had happened to her at the time. She told me she had been assaulted and knocked unconscious by a female,” he said.
Garda Foley said the girl was taken to hospital by ambulance but her injuries went undiagnosed due to the severe swelling to her face and nose.
She subsequently attended her own GP and was diagnosed with a broken nose and displaced septum. She was referred back to hospital where she underwent surgery to have her nose broken again and reset.
The girl suffered damage to muscles in her jaw and could not open her mouth properly after the attack. She is still undergoing physiotherapy treatment for that injury.
Garda Foley said he obtained CCTV footage from MacSwiggan’s three days later which captured the assault and clearly identified Keary.
He arrested her by appointment at Galway Garda Station in September and on seeing the CCTV footage, she readily admitted her involvement.
Garda Foley said the injured girl was “a very decent girl from a very decent family.”
He said the girl was too afraid to come to court.
“She is extremely traumatised and she does not want to see the defendant again and feels that if the defendant sees her again there will be repercussions,” Garda Foley said.
He then read her victim impact statement to the court on her behalf.
In it, the girl said she was viciously attacked by a woman who had violently clawed at her and pulled her out onto the road by her hair.
“I have lived in Galway all my life and I have never experienced such a brutal event.
“I no longer feel safe in my own town. I have no comfort on a night out with friends as I am always looking over my shoulder,” the girl’s statement read.
Keary, Garda Foley said, was well known to Gardai already and had 25 previous convictions, the last being in December 2012, for a serious assault for which she had received a six-month sentence.
“She has a long history of alcohol and drug abuse,” he added.
Defence barrister, John Kiely said his client had taken drugs and alcohol on the night of the attack.
Mr Kiely said there was no excuse for what his client did, but it was not premeditated and occurred because of some mistaken perceived insult.
Mr Kiely said Keary had been under the direction of the probation service previously and while she had been accepted for treatment at two residential treatment centres in the past – at Coolmine and at Bushy Park – she had failed to co-operate in any way with treatment or with the probation service.
Since then, he said, there had been new development’s in that Keary’s father has come back into her life and he was present in court.
The second important development, Mr Kiely said, was that there had been disclosure of “a significant life event” that occurred during her childhood, which was an incident of distress to her and that had not been dealt with in any way by her or by any of the support services.
Of even more importance, Mr Kiely said, was that Keary was now prepared to address her addiction issues and other issues in her life and if the court was willing to put a stay on sentencing, his client would do just that.
Judge McCabe said he was inclined to remand Keary in custody and she could be assessed while in custody.
Mr Kiely said that was an option but he asked the Judge not to do that so that she could be psychiatrically assessed.
Judge McCabe said that could be done more expeditiously while she was in custody.
Mr Kiely again asked him not to do that. He said a curfew could be imposed on her which would serve to protect the community until such time as she received treatment.
He said his client had not come to Garda attention since this incident.
Garda Foley disagreed and said Keary had been arrested on five separate occasions since and has 11 other charges currently pending before the courts for alleged assault, robbery and fraud offences.
Mr Kiely apologised and said he had not been made aware of this.
Judge McCabe persisted, saying he didn’t see why the necessary assessments could not be done while Keary was in custody.
However, following further submissions from Mr Kiely he relented and adjourned the matter to next Friday’s court.
“If you do not have a timetable in place by then Mr Kiely, I will lay out a timetable for her and it will be in custody,” the judge warned.
Blue Teapot instilling creativity in people with intellectual disabilities
Graduation day at Blue Teapot’s Performing Arts School for people with intellectual disabilities can be bitter-sweet, according to the school’s co-ordinator, Ana Belle Alvarez.
“In some ways, you feel very sad when they’re gone when they graduate. After three years of sharing moments, and sharing so many things, it can be sad. But then it’s exciting when you have the new people coming in as well,” she said.
The Performing Arts School at Munster Avenue in the city is one strand of the Blue Teapot brand, which is now inviting new recruits for the semester beginning next September.
The other better-known strand is its Ensemble, also based at Munster Avenue, which includes a professional troupe of actors, who stage performances at their own theatre space and elsewhere, throughout the year.
One aim of those who join the former is, ultimately, to land a role in the latter.
“That’s the dream. We don’t have the capacity (to meet demand) but that’s the aim of everyone,” said Ana, a Spaniard, who has been with Blue Teapot for almost six years.
Many in the professional Ensemble were schooled in the Blue Teapot Performing Arts School.
Two students who graduated last year are now part of the 11-strong Ensemble, which had two spaces available.
But even those who don’t progress to a professional career in theatre with Blue Teapot will benefit from the course which is Quality and Qualifications Ireland (QQI) accredited, according to one of a handful of well-known teachers at the school, Rod Goodall.
“To be trained in the arts – drama, dance, music and so – does not mean that the student will achieve a career in these disciplines. It means that they’ll enjoy more creativity, more confidence and be better equipped for social interactions in their lives,” said the drama tutor and theatre director.
There is some crossover, though.
“Sometimes, it has been the case where the students of the Performing Arts School, participate in a production with the professional actors,” explained Ana.
“Parallel to that, our drama teacher sometimes produces a theatre show just for the students to showcase to their family members,” she said.
The three-year programme leads to a certification in QQI Levels 2 and 3. It is an opportunity for people with intellectual disabilities, who are aged 18 and over, to access formal training.
Modules include drama, music, drawing, costume, design and event participation. The programme also incorporates life-skills training including interpersonal skills, online safety, health and fitness.
Literacy and IT supports are provided by Galway Adult Basic Education Services.
“Every training programme is very structured and the students work really hard in the classes, learning so many skills and it’s all very practical but they have fun as well,” said Ana.
When asked to describe the sort of people with intellectual disabilities the school is looking to recruit, Ana said: “Anyone who has a passion for the arts; a passion for performing arts; anyone who has a passion for the theatre.”
School is on Monday to Thursday, 10am-3pm. Much of the programme focuses on personal development where learners can fulfil their artistic potential.
“To be able to develop their own potential and their own ideas, everything we do with tutors is based in the student’s own creativity and their own ideas. If they’re creating a mask, for example, it’s based on their own research of what they like, and they transform what they like, and their own personality and creativity, and they transfer that into their final work,” she said.
The company liaises with organisations such as Ability West and Brothers of Charity during its recruitment drive, and it also contacts schools for school-leavers with intellectual disabilities who are seeking a new challenge.
Ana’s biggest problem is that they have capacity for an intake of just five people every year.
“It’s very hard because we have many people applying for the Performing Arts School, and we only have five places. You’d love to take everyone, but the reality is we don’t have the capacity,” she said.
“Photo: Blue Teapot members Michael Hayes and Valerie Egan on the set designed by Sabine Dargent and with costumes designed by Charmian Goodall).
Taoiseach to look at Minor Injuries Unit for Galway
An Taoiseach Leo Varadkar has said the Government will consider a new Minor Injuries Unit for Galway.
During Leaders Questions in the Dáil on Tuesday, Independent TD for Galway West, Noel Grealish made the case for a new Minor Injuries Unit (MIU).
Deputy Grealish said there are 15 of these MIUs dotted around the country, but none in Galway . . . and they are proven to help relieve pressure in Emergency Departments.
“The Emergency Department at UHG remains one of the busiest in the country, without the relief that would be provided by thousands of people being redirected to a Minor Injuries Unit,” he said.
Mr Varadkar replied that MIUs worked extremely well “with people with minor injuries not having to go to very busy and crowded emergency departments and, more important, people with minor injuries who need to be seen and to receive healthcare getting that healthcare in an uncrowded and more humane setting within a few hours.
“We are happy to give consideration to a Minor Injury Unit for Galway but I am not at liberty to make that commitment here and now. We will certainly take it seriously, however,” said An Taoiseach.
Deputy Grealish has also stated that it is unrealistic to believe that a new elective hospital for Galway could be built within four or five years.
“Realistically, it could take 15 years or more, given that the recently-opened radiotherapy unit in Galway took over 14 years to deliver.
“And the Taoiseach himself acknowledged in his response to me that so many important projects in the west have been delayed, particularly the emergency department and the paediatric and maternity units at University Hospital Galway, which, in his own words, should have been under construction by now, let alone have gone to planning.
“Given the track record of the HSE in delivering projects, I believe that a new elective hospital could be years away and a minor injuries unit should be provided in Galway to help provide some relief. I intend to pursue this further with the Minister for Health and the HSE over the coming months,” Deputy Grealish said.
Groundbreaking coronary operation at UHG offers vision of future healthcare
The announcement this week that Galway University Hospitals carried out the first robotic guided coronary intervention in Ireland and UK, has given researchers a glimpse into the future possibilities presented by this medical breakthrough.
Currently, University Hospital Galway is the centre of excellence for cardiovascular medicine for one million people in the West and North West.
It’s where patients from Sligo, Donegal and elsewhere go for coronary procedures, such as the insertion of stents to relieve blockages in the arteries of the heart.
That involves hours of travel, on top of lengthy procedures, which can be exhausting for patients.
But one potential benefit of new robotic technology is the prospect of remote procedures, explained Professor Faisal Sharif, Consultant Cardiologist, who carried out the first procedure in Ireland or UK, at UHG.
“I think we will see in the future more advantages, and value, when these procedures can be done remotely,” Prof Sharif told the Tribune.
This would involve a patient going to Sligo University Hospital or Letterkenny University Hospital to have a stent procedure, which would be carried out via the internet by a robotic ‘hand’ controlled by a consultant cardiologist based at UHG.
Obviously, the basic structures and a trained crew would need to be available in Sligo or Letterkenny, including nurses and junior doctors.
And Prof Sharif cautioned that for remote procedures to become reality here, there needs to be more research and development and more funding.
“That’s the potential and that’s the future but it hasn’t come yet,” he said.
What has come is exciting, too, though.
Before Christmas, Prof Sharif carried out three procedures which combined the benefits of coronary intervention with the precision of robotics.
The new technology is used in stent procedures to relieve blockages in the arteries of the heart. It allows for greater precision in positioning stents, allowing the interventional cardiologists to move the stent a millimetre at a time.
It also allows the medical team to have an enhanced, close-up view of the angiographic images and information during the entire procedure.
The new technology allows interventional cardiologists to use the robot as an extension of their own hand, allowing for robotic precision and details visualisation when positioning of guide catheters, guide-wires and balloon or stent catheters.
Prof Sharif said the technology was beneficial both to the patient and to the cardiologist.
“The main advantage of robotics is that it is safe and very precise in stent placement. It allows the accurate placement for up to 1mm at a time,” he said.
For the patient, this increased precision means less metallic material in the arteries, “and so less long-term side effects from that metal”.
The use of robotics also benefits staff, meaning fewer back injuries, less exposure to radiation and more precise placement of stents, he said.
Prof Sharif said UHG would be performing these procedures more regularly. They’ve started with straightforward cases, and over time, when they understand more about it, and the volume increases, they will increase complexity.
Seven more procedures are planned for the next fortnight but won’t entirely replace the traditional method, he said.
“Physicians learn a technique to do things over many years. That’s our livelihood, that’s what we do. If we bring machines in, there is going to be resistance. But at the moment, it’s to see the positive side of things, see how it can improve outcomes, how it can do things more safely, how it can take the load off physicians, who will still be fully trained to do it.
“It is just assistance. I think we need to learn what the potential is. It won’t replace anything. If any hospital has 10 operators, four or five may adopt it, others may stay the traditional way. I think the change will be slow. But I hope over time when they see the results they might like to change,” he said.
Originally from Pakistan, Prof Sharif’s home for 26 years is Ireland. As well as clinical work, the academic part of his job involves University of Galway tutoring and research commitments.
He’s a founder member of a university programme on medical device innovation called BioInnovate Ireland, which has developed start-ups over 10 years.
That synergy, as well as funding through Science Foundation Ireland, led to the first robotic procedure in Ireland and the UK taking place in Galway.
“In Galway we have a big medical device sector. It’s the ideal place to be for medical device developments, especially cardiovascular,” he added.
Chris Kane, General Manager of Galway University Hospitals welcomed the new technology.
“Innovations such as this are transforming medicine . . . this state-of-the-art robotics will enhance patient care for our patients across the West and Northwest of Ireland,” she added.
(Photo: The robotic guided coronary intervention at UHG. It was the first such procedure in Ireland and the UK).